What are the downstream and upstream determinants? The path to recovery and good health is shaped by several variables outside our own control or personal decisions.
These elements, referred to as “determinants of health,” have a significant impact on our mental and physical health. These variables are frequently divided into “upstream” and “downstream” elements in the context of public health discourse.
Understanding the many factors that affect our health journey gives us the ability to better navigate the road to recovery, viewing each stage as a crucial component of our individual recovery narrative.
What are the downstream and upstream determinants?
When we ask: What are the downstream and upstream determinants? We should know that upstream determinants are large-scale, systemic factors that contribute to health disparities, such as economic structures, policies, and social norms; downstream determinants, on the other hand, are more individual-level factors or immediate issues that are symptoms of the underlying upstream issues, such as individual behavior or access to immediate care.
The “river analogy” makes this easier to see, with downstream signifying the immediate effects like poor health outcomes and upstream signifying the causes of the issues like poverty, systematic discrimination.
Understanding Upstream Determinants
A complex, multi-layered causal chain influences individual health, and upstream determinants include macro-level, basic social elements such as economic systems, public policy, and structural injustices that set the stage for both positive and negative health outcomes.
Root reasons like systematic discrimination, structural elements like government subsidies or housing and health-related legislation, and essential inputs like clean water systems or public education that allow for equitable health for whole populations are all included.
Since these upstream variables influence the “rules of the game” that decide who benefits and who is disadvantaged, addressing them is essential for long-term health equity.
Examples:
Examples include supply chain raw materials that impact product availability and pricing, economic regulations like minimum wage legislation or taxes, environmental factors like access to clean water, and social determinants of health (SDOH) like systemic racism and educational opportunities.
The underlying causes of these macro-level factors are what have a cascading influence on people’s behavior and health.
Role in ESG:
A firm’s Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance is greatly influenced by upstream factors such as company policies and sourcing choices, which have an impact on labor practices, environmental impact, and overall sustainability through supplier involvement and selection.
Strict corporate rules, for example, might require sustainable procurement, which encourages suppliers to adopt more environmentally friendly procedures and improve working conditions, thereby raising the company’s ESG image.
Understanding Downstream Determinants
The immediate elements that have the greatest direct impact on results are known as downstream determinants. Examples of these include the tangible goods and services that a project produces (outputs) and the advantages or modifications that they provide to people and communities (outcomes).
Upstream variables (environmental and structural) are at the top of the chain of impact, followed by midstream factors (over which people have greater power) and downstream factors.
Organizations may create more successful interventions that go beyond only generating outputs to accomplish significant and long-lasting impacts by having a better understanding of these many levels.
Examples:
Unlike upstream systemic influences, downstream determinants are unique, individual-level situations and factors that affect health outcomes.
Examples include the direct effects of a community impact program on the well-being of a local population, the health condition of customers, the influence of product quality on human health, and exposure to emissions at the individual or community level.
Role in ESG:
The indirect greenhouse gas emissions produced by consumers as they use and discard a company’s goods and services are known as downstream determinants for ESG, or more precisely, Scope 3 emissions.
The “product use phase” is a significant downstream determinant, during which emissions are caused by energy used by items such as automobiles, appliances, or other elements associated with their continuous running.
A company’s ESG performance may be greatly impacted by comprehending and controlling these downstream effects, which are essential for achieving overall sustainability goals.
The Difference Between Upstream and Downstream Determinants
What are the downstream and upstream determinants? Upstream determinants are societal and structural elements that affect population-level health, such as economic systems, environmental issues, and governmental policies.
Individual actions, lifestyle decisions, and the availability of prompt medical treatment are examples of downstream determinants, which are personal variables that have a direct impact on an individual’s health and well-being.
Like a causal chain, upstream causes influence the settings that result in numerous downstream effects, with systemic problems generating the conditions that affect people. The following table shows the main differences:
Upstream Determinants | Downstream Determinants | |
Level | Social, macro, and systemic | Micro-level, individual |
Focus | Structural adjustments, long-term remedies, and underlying causes | Personal habits, current issues, and temporary fixes |
Examples | Government regulations on work and housing. Institutionalized prejudice. Availability of wholesome meals in a neighborhood. Economic and educational systems. | Personal health habits, such as diet or smoking. Access to prompt medical attention and care. Job position or educational attainment of the individual. |
Goal | By changing social structures and policies, we may alleviate disparities and promote healthier settings. | Lessen the impact of upstream difficulties and offer resources and assistance to those who are dealing with health concerns. |
Why classification matters in strategy, business, and policy?
Strategy: Distinguishing between upstream and downstream factors allows for a more comprehensive and effective strategic approach.
A strategy focusing only on downstream issues provides temporary fixes, while incorporating upstream solutions addresses systemic problems, leading to long-term, sustainable change.
Business: In a supply chain, upstream activities involve sourcing raw materials and components, while downstream activities focus on manufacturing, marketing, and delivering the final product to the consumer.
Classifying these stages is essential for managing the entire value chain, from raw material acquisition to customer delivery, and for optimizing efficiency and profitability.
Policy: Understanding upstream and downstream determinants is critical for designing effective health and social policies.
Upstream policies can prevent issues by changing societal structures, while downstream interventions provide necessary services and support for those already experiencing hardship. A balanced approach that combines both levels leads to greater health equity and social well-being.
Conclusion
You have correctly summed up. What are the downstream and upstream determinants? The underlying causes and essential inputs that mold the environment and systems are known as upstream determinants. These include structural conditions, policies, and socioeconomic variables.
Individual behaviors, the emergence of illnesses, and eventually death are examples of downstream determinants, which are the direct results and outputs that follow from these upstream effects.
The paradigm depicts a “causal chain” in which systemic upstream causes direct downstream health impacts, followed by intermediary effects.
Finally, we must note to you the importance of IDCE 2025 because it is the leading venue for showcasing downstream innovation and strategic alignment with upstream factors.